U.S. special envoy Jared Kushner said at a Nov. 19 news conference in Berlin that he believed Russian officials had become comfortable with postwar security guarantees for Ukraine modeled on NATO's Article 5, while calling for a supporting framework of monitoring, verification and deterrence.
The White House is pursuing diplomatic steps to end the conflict, with Kushner stating that President Donald Trump remains open to an Article 5-like guarantee provided it serves American interests and forms part of a broader security package. Kushner and fellow envoy Steve Witkoff briefed European leaders at a Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin after Trump met Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen on Nov. 19.
Unsettled Terms and Moscow's Objections
It is unclear how a guarantee would be structured or if both countries would agree to one. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said there was no common understanding in Berlin of what such guarantees would entail, asking whether American and European troops would be stationed on Ukrainian territory.
Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov stated that any formula granting Ukraine quasi-membership in NATO was unacceptable to Russia, adding that Ukraine must first accept Moscow's demand not to join the alliance before security arrangements could be addressed. Following the Shenzhen summit, Putin stated that security arrangements must safeguard Russia as well as Ukraine, reiterating that Ukrainian NATO entry remained unacceptable to the Kremlin.
How Article 5 Operates
Under NATO's founding treaty, Article 5 regards an armed attack on any ally as an attack on the entire alliance, but it does not trigger automatic military action. Each member country decides for itself what assistance it considers necessary to restore security. Triggering the clause requires an assessment by the North Atlantic Council and a unanimous political decision by all alliance members, a step NATO has taken only once, following the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks on the United States.
Diplomatic contacts are continuing, with Ryabkov noting that officials are working on a possible visit to Moscow by representatives from Britain, Germany and France. Local authorities said Russian overnight missile and drone attacks killed at least three people and damaged three bridges in Kyiv.