On Friday, the full Fifth Circuit ruled 9-8 that the House passed a spending package containing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act without the required quorum. It retained an order barring the Justice Department and Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the provision against Texas.
It is not yet known which individual workers or employers fall under the injunction. Enacted as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, the measure requires employers to grant reasonable accommodations to pregnant workers, such as access to water, restroom breaks, less lifting and leave for prenatal appointments. In 2022, the House approved the broader $1.7 trillion bill by 225 votes to 201. A total of 226 members voted by proxy after lawmakers allowed remote and proxy voting as a safety precaution during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Constitutional Quorum Standards
Under the Constitution's quorum clause, each chamber of Congress needs more than half its members for a quorum to conduct business. The majority held that more than half of House members must be in personal attendance and that proxy votes cannot be counted toward establishing that threshold.
Judge James Graves dissented, arguing that the majority introduced an in-person attendance rule not found in the text of the Constitution's quorum clause. Earlier lawsuits challenging remote procedures had been rejected by other federal courts, which concluded that the Constitution's Speech or Debate Clause barred those cases.
Contested Scope Across States
Advocacy group A Better Balance claimed the decision effectively invalidates the pregnancy accommodation law in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, noting that roughly 20 million women reside in those three states combined. In contrast, Judge Cory Wilson's reported view is that the decision applies only to Texas's legal challenge.
A three-judge Fifth Circuit panel previously upheld the statute's enactment in August 2025, but that ruling was vacated when the full appeals court granted rehearing en banc in January 2026. An appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court is reported to be expected.